User Login

Welcome to the new home of the Cafe. The Cafe has been serving retro goodness since 1999. If you were a previous member of the Atomic Magazine or the Port Halcyon Cafe Forums please click on "Forgot your password?" which is located in the left column to get a new password. Your old user name has been reserved for you. We look forward to talking with you!


sailor-man
useravatar
User Info

So What Really Killed Swing

In another post, someone mentioned an old post about what killed the swing dance scene.  I think it is a good topic to revisit an discuss, because I really enjoyed the scene, and miss it greatly [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/sad.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
CharlieH.
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

It was the sparrow, with his bow and arrow, nyuk, nyuk&#33;

(ok, back to our regularly scheduled conversation)


Administrator has disabled public posting
Jay
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I used to go to the Five Spot in Society Hill in Philadelphia early in the evening. While I was having a drink at the bar there would be couples on the dance floor practicing their routines(&#33;) for later on. The same six couples would hog the dance floor, and casual dancers were forced off to the side. It wasn&#39;t fun anymore. I think that pretty much happened at all the clubs across America.

In slightly good news, the girl I am currently seeing wants to learn, and in some Internet searches I&#39;ve found places that still do it.  We start lessons on Sunday---I could use a crash course myself.


Administrator has disabled public posting
sailor-man
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I also noticed, that the "elite dancers" wouldn&#39;t dance with any of the new people, and I guess the newbies were intimidated, or discouraged from coming.  They couldn&#39;t learn much dancing on their own. 

I think that some of the spectators crowded the floor too.

I seem to remember that a lot of dancers wouldn&#39;t drink.  Often the brought their own water, or just drank free glasses of water instead of buying non-alchololic beverages from the bar.  Therefore, the venues weren&#39;t making any money, and favored other dance nights that weren&#39;t so stressed about maintaining perfrect form and drank, like Latin Dance nights, etc. 

In either case I&#39;m a bit miffed about it. [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/mad.gif[/img]  I really enjoyed the scene.  I went to a swing night here, but it was in a cafeteria, they weren&#39;t selling any type of beverage--they never even turned the lights down&#33;  I guess, I enjoyed the whole 1930s-40s night club experience, and not just the dancing. 

Here&#39;s hoping it comes back again&#33;&#33;&#33; [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/cool.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
Marlowe
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

<!--quoteo(post=81773:date=Jul 6 2006, 09&#58;18 PM:name=sailor&#045;man)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(sailor&#045;man &#064; Jul 6 2006, 09&#58;18 PM) [snapback]81773[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
I also noticed, that the "elite dancers" wouldn&#39;t dance with any of the new people, and I guess the newbies were intimidated, or discouraged from coming.  They couldn&#39;t learn much dancing on their own. 

I think that some of the spectators crowded the floor too.

I seem to remember that a lot of dancers wouldn&#39;t drink.  Often the brought their own water, or just drank free glasses of water instead of buying non-alchololic beverages from the bar.  Therefore, the venues weren&#39;t making any money, and favored other dance nights that weren&#39;t so stressed about maintaining perfrect form and drank, like Latin Dance nights, etc. 

In either case I&#39;m a bit miffed about it. [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/mad.gif[/img]  I really enjoyed the scene.  I went to a swing night here, but it was in a cafeteria, they weren&#39;t selling any type of beverage--they never even turned the lights down&#33;  I guess, I enjoyed the whole 1930s-40s night club experience, and not just the dancing. 

Here&#39;s hoping it comes back again&#33;&#33;&#33; [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/cool.gif[/img]

You&#39;re dead-on with that, Sailor Man.  Elitism in these little subcultures becomes unbearable and the time spent socializing with "like minded" people becomes just as torturous as a night on the town with brain dead "Gangstas" and Jocks...superficiality rears it&#39;s ugly head again.  But luckily here in F-L-A, there&#39;s no retro scene, so problem (and fun) averted&#33; [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/rolleyes.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
swingin_suzi
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I&#39;m telling you, it was Blyers.  and I&#39;m sticking to my guns on that one.  [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/wink.gif[/img]

SwS


Administrator has disabled public posting
Chrissy
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I agree with the cheapskate theory.  Swing dancers don&#39;t run up bar (or food) tabs.  When swing was trendy, a lot of marginal people would come out and presumably did spend &#036;.  But when the trend dwindled, the serious dancers were left, the ones who didn&#39;t buy anything.  So all the restaurant/nightclub venues in the DC area that used to have swing dance nights dried up.  There are still plenty of places to dance, but not much in the way of true retro nightclubs.  Doc Scantlin still produces 1930s nightclub events, but it&#39;s not expressly for swing dancers.  And the dancers don&#39;t tend to come out for Doc, anyway.  Another problem is that dancers don&#39;t tend to dress anymore-- I&#39;d hate to have a legion of dancers show up at a night club event in sneakers and jeans. 

As for the &#39;elite dancers,&#39; I&#39;m not sure why they&#39;re so coveted, frankly.  I mean, I can see that the situation generates resentment.  But it&#39;s not as if they&#39;re the only people worth dancing with.  There are a lot of good dancers who aren&#39;t in the little &#39;elite&#39; group.  So I&#39;m not sure how much of a deterant that is.


<!--quoteo(post=81773:date=Jul 6 2006, 08&#58;18 PM:name=sailor&#045;man)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(sailor&#045;man &#064; Jul 6 2006, 08&#58;18 PM) [snapback]81773[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
I also noticed, that the "elite dancers" wouldn&#39;t dance with any of the new people, and I guess the newbies were intimidated, or discouraged from coming.  They couldn&#39;t learn much dancing on their own. 

I think that some of the spectators crowded the floor too.

I seem to remember that a lot of dancers wouldn&#39;t drink.  Often the brought their own water, or just drank free glasses of water instead of buying non-alchololic beverages from the bar.  Therefore, the venues weren&#39;t making any money, and favored other dance nights that weren&#39;t so stressed about maintaining perfrect form and drank, like Latin Dance nights, etc. 

In either case I&#39;m a bit miffed about it. [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/mad.gif[/img]  I really enjoyed the scene.  I went to a swing night here, but it was in a cafeteria, they weren&#39;t selling any type of beverage--they never even turned the lights down&#33;  I guess, I enjoyed the whole 1930s-40s night club experience, and not just the dancing. 

Here&#39;s hoping it comes back again&#33;&#33;&#33; [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/cool.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
sailor-man
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

<!--quoteo(post=82063:date=Jul 17 2006, 04&#58;23 PM:name=Chrissy)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Chrissy &#064; Jul 17 2006, 04&#58;23 PM) [snapback]82063[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
As for the &#39;elite dancers,&#39; I&#39;m not sure why they&#39;re so coveted, frankly.  I mean, I can see that the situation generates resentment.  But it&#39;s not as if they&#39;re the only people worth dancing with.  There are a lot of good dancers who aren&#39;t in the little &#39;elite&#39; group.  So I&#39;m not sure how much of a deterant that is.

I don&#39;t know.  I think it just gave off a negative vibe, and people didn&#39;t want to be associated with it.


Administrator has disabled public posting
Canuck
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I think both main points are true. The fact that the local club didn&#39;t make much money on alcohol sales certainly was a factor in our scene closing down. The local dance club did try to include people as much as possible, with frequent lessons offered between sets at swing nights, but for some reason, it just couldn&#39;t maintain momentum.

What&#39;s frustrating is that the swing scene gets a hugely popular reaction when put on display publicly (open air concerts, etc.) but I think a lot of people are intimidated by the thought of needing to learn steps. How many generations to this point have only learned to "dance" by spasming in vague proximity to someone who may or may not be their partner?

I&#39;ve also found that many people see swing as just a fad that came and went a number of years ago, and anyone ho still likes that kind of music and dancing is passe. I know I&#39;ve seen this attitude reinforced by local media reviews of new discs by people like Brian Setzer, where the artist is dismissed for "still" producing swing or rockabilly. They even seem insulted by it&#33;


Administrator has disabled public posting
Canuck
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

So having lamented the "end" of the swing craze, what can we do, as a smallish but frantic community of retro-lifestyle afficianados, do to re-vitalize it?


Administrator has disabled public posting
swingin_suzi
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

Teach all your friends to dance and then rool up the rug and have fabulous parties in the living room?


SwS


Administrator has disabled public posting
Chrissy
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

What can we do?  I&#39;d suggest start up retro cocktail hours.


Administrator has disabled public posting
SORTEGA76
Port Halcyon Veteran
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

<!--quoteo(post=82127:date=Jul 19 2006, 10&#58;00 AM:name=Chrissy)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Chrissy &#064; Jul 19 2006, 10&#58;00 AM) [snapback]82127[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
What can we do?  I&#39;d suggest start up retro cocktail hours.

I&#39;d have to agree with this one. Many things killed swing, but a lack of venues certainly sped the process along. Yes, many of the swing dancers were there for the dancing and drank bottled water. Heck, I know several churches that sponsored swing events as a way to give "the kids" a fun night where drinking wouldn&#39;t be involved. How THAT association got made, I&#39;ll never know&#33;

Anyway, bars got tired of not making money on drinks so they went with other venues. Retro cocktail hours are fun. Tuesday nights in Champaign there is a great tiki/lounge event hosted by <a href="http://www.javasbachelorpad.com/" target="_blank">Java&#39;s Bachelor Pad</a>. The bars love it because a crowd of people drinking on a Tuesday night is VERY good business and people love dressing up in 50&#39;s gear. One of the things I envy New York is their active Lounge scene (<a href="http://www.tommywhitetie.com/main.php" target="_blank">Tommy White Tie</a>).

There is enough room for a variety of retro events. I certainly like the silly, somewhat informal Tiki stuff but I really yearn for the days when a swing night brought out guys in suits and fedoras and the gals got dolled up in dresses. I&#39;d kill for a real nightclub evening with dinnersuits and gowns and a live band, especially on NYE.  I&#39;d love a bar that had a decent drink list, a dress code that forbade t-shirts and allowed cigar smoking but those things aren&#39;t going to happen.

The great thing is that any of these are possible IF you get enough people on board who will make it worth the bar owner&#39;s while. That can be a giant IF. I&#39;ve got some friends who dabble in party/event promotion. It&#39;s really all about the money you can bring in to a bar owner. Sure, some bar owners don&#39;t mind eating a loss for a charity event or an event they REALLY believe n, but most can&#39;t afford to do it. They have enormous taxes to pay, hassles from the city, rent/mortgage, cleaning costs, etc. In town, one of the biggest hip-hop bars is run at a bar that used to be a gay bar until the owner decided to switch "themes" for more money. Remember that bars and nightlife are a business.


"All of us are lying in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars."
--Oscar Wilde

Administrator has disabled public posting
Canuck
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

These are GREAT ideas&#33; I certainly agree with SORTEGA76 that bars are a business and need to look to the bottom line, so any retro event needs to be sold and sold well.

I think there&#39;s enough diversity in retro-themed events that a creative group could probably maintain interest and profitability for any willing venue. A few ideas that pop off the top of my head include:

Tiki lounge night
Retro fifties drive-in night
Swing/Supper club night
Sixties Vegas casino-themed night
Vintage fashion-show night (with vintage cocktails, of course)
Movie-themed nights (maybe a Casablanca night or a James Dean night)

Of course, what this may involve is having a committed group who would be willing to stage and help promote these events. Kind of like a festival committee, but devoted to sharing the joys of retro-culture. At least until someone in the group is able to purchase their own venue.


Administrator has disabled public posting
SORTEGA76
Port Halcyon Veteran
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

Depending on the state of your hometown, you may want to consider pairing with a local Historical Society. You may want to lose the drinks at the nightclub for something like a picnic (see the hugely successful Gatsby Picnic threads). Of course, there&#39;s no guarantee that the love of history and old buildings won&#39;t get you a group of shabbily dressed hippies but you may get lucky. I would suggest that any event have a bonus to dress in retro, or at least a suit and tie. Sell tickets at the door that give a discount for dressing appropriately.


"All of us are lying in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars."
--Oscar Wilde

Administrator has disabled public posting
Canuck
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

Doing tie-ins with local classic car clubs would be another natural. I know Sunday night here is "cruise night", where everyone who owns a classic car or hot rod shows off their work

How about antique or second hand furniture stores? I&#39;m sure they would love to have another venue to show off their goods. If done well, this coudl turn into, if you&#39;ll pardon the use of a horriblety overworked phrase, a "retro-palooza"


Administrator has disabled public posting
MoonMoth
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

<!--quoteo(post=81644:date=Jun 30 2006, 07&#58;41 PM:name=sailor&#045;man)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(sailor&#045;man &#064; Jun 30 2006, 07&#58;41 PM) [snapback]81644[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
In another post, someone mentioned an old post about what killed the swing dance scene.  I think it is a good topic to revisit an discuss, because I really enjoyed the scene, and miss it greatly [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/sad.gif[/img]

Here&#39;s the relevant links, if you are interested:

Read the Swankman&#39;s excellent commentary about the arrogance creeping up in the Swing scene, with Indigo Swing showing up 45 minutes late to a show:

    <a href="http://www.porthalcyon.net/community/index.php?showtopic=1170" target="_blank">http://www.porthalcyon.net/community/index...?showtopic=1170</a>

Also:

    <a href="http://www.porthalcyon.net/community/index.php?showtopic=1177" target="_blank">http://www.porthalcyon.net/community/index...?showtopic=1177</a>   

I missed the entire era myself, except for hearing a few Squirrel Nut Zippers tunes on the radio at the time, but you owe it to yourself to go read those threads from a few years ago, to get the historical perspective from old-time Atomic&#39;ers who were first-hand participants, many  who sadly are no longer contributing here.

Not to say, of course, that new commentary is not welcome on this topic.  My only opinion is that all modern music trends (e.g. ska, rockabilly, synth, boy bands, swing, surf, grunge, Norwegian goat yodelling) eventually get to the point where the money moves in, and neutralizes the creativeness and accesibility that got the scene off the ground in the first place. 


Administrator has disabled public posting
Lost Soul
Red Under the Bed
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

It&#39;s all academic to me as the swing revival never really reached these shores.

I just go out, get drunk, dance. Works for me. With the aid of a few lessons of course.

I&#39;d Lindy to punk so long as the tempo was right.


Administrator has disabled public posting
Guest
Guest
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I think one of the things that killed the swing scene was that tv played up aerials and tricks. People didn&#39;t realize that it takes time to get to that point and there are "baby steps" in the meantime. I think people wanted to start out flying through the air, but didn&#39;t want to put in the time or effort so they got bored and quit.

Same thing happens in the Burlesque scene. Someone will see me perform and want to do it, but they don&#39;t realize that it took me months to put together my 6 min routine, make my costume, make the contacts, plus when I started out I sank more money in than I got out. So when they beg me to help them perform, they end up giving up because it is too much work.

Weither it is Swing or Burlesque, they see the final product and want to do it, but they don&#39;t want to work for it.  [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/sad.gif[/img]

Administrator has disabled public posting
swingin_suzi
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

Miss Lolita is certainly right - people are lazy.  Burlesque has a stronger future, I think, because it is something spectators can enjoy watching and not feel bad about actually participating in, whereas swing dancing is something people need to try.

No matter though what exactly killed "Swing," it is dead.  I loved it, and I  have often wondered where all those people who dressed up and danced so suavely while not being afraid to enjoy a few martinis went.  I think I know, now.  They are still around, living normal lives with a retro flair, being the only one at the supermarket in heels and a perfect coif, and bidding up all the auctions I want to win to rediculous prices&#33;  The show up for burlesque events and rockabilly events, they are happy to enjoy what is out there.  Life goes on, and while I will always remember fondly the days of the Hi-Ball Lounge, I&#39;m not afraid to enjoy the rest of my life.  We create our own worlds and our own enviornments; I can be happy about Louis Prima on my hi-fi, and be just as happy to go and see Big Sandy live - it&#39;s all in your perception.  There are tons of retro things to do out there, you just have to find them&#33;

SwS

P.S.  If there is a drive-in movie theatre in your town, patronize it&#33;  They are disappearing all over the planet.  [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/biggrin.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
retrogirl
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I think swing was hyped a great deal in the 90s, and as it was the cool thing to do, a lot of people joined in.  When the media moved on to something new, so did the trendoid population.  In Arizona, swing was rpelaced by salsa.  We still get a good crowd, with a lot of younger newbies, but no wants to be bothered to dress up--they&#39;re too cool for that.  Many that once did dress up no longer do so--the put out an air of "it&#39;s all about the dance".  Most of the people who jumped on the trend have abandoned all aspects of the lifestyle look in the personal lives as well.  It&#39;s too much work and people can&#39;t be bothered [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/rolleyes.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
Guest
Guest
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I know... it makes me sad... as I would like to look at some of those cuties on Wednesday dressed up&#33; There are a handful of boys there that I think would melt my heart if they had the style&#33; [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif[/img] As it is I am terribly attracted to them because they can dance.

~Lolita


<!--quoteo(post=82301:date=Jul 27 2006, 10&#58;03 AM:name=retrogirl)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(retrogirl &#064; Jul 27 2006, 10&#58;03 AM) [snapback]82301[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
I think swing was hyped a great deal in the 90s, and as it was the cool thing to do, a lot of people joined in.  When the media moved on to something new, so did the trendoid population.  In Arizona, swing was rpelaced by salsa.  We still get a good crowd, with a lot of younger newbies, but no wants to be bothered to dress up--they&#39;re too cool for that.  Many that once did dress up no longer do so--the put out an air of "it&#39;s all about the dance".  Most of the people who jumped on the trend have abandoned all aspects of the lifestyle look in the personal lives as well.  It&#39;s too much work and people can&#39;t be bothered [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/rolleyes.gif[/img]

Administrator has disabled public posting
sailor-man
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

<!--quoteo(post=82127:date=Jul 19 2006, 11&#58;00 AM:name=Chrissy)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Chrissy &#064; Jul 19 2006, 11&#58;00 AM) [snapback]82127[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
What can we do?  I&#39;d suggest start up retro cocktail hours.

I like this idea very much&#33; [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/cool.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting
sailor-man
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

<!--quoteo(post=82301:date=Jul 27 2006, 12&#58;03 PM:name=retrogirl)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(retrogirl &#064; Jul 27 2006, 12&#58;03 PM) [snapback]82301[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->
We still get a good crowd, with a lot of younger newbies, but no wants to be bothered to dress up--they&#39;re too cool for that.  Many that once did dress up no longer do so--the put out an air of "it&#39;s all about the dance". 

I remember the Bash on Ash had a couple of great dance nights, till we lost that venue.  They used to play retro movies on the big screen, and brought in some nice bands.  A lot did dress up, and there were a lot of loungers too that dressed, especially the "Blue Martini Pages" guys.  You&#39;re right it did get this "all about the dance" jive, and it seemed people got more into how to rock step properly, than just having fun&#33;  Of course if they did get a cocktail, that might ruin their rock steps.


Administrator has disabled public posting
retrogirl
useravatar
User Info

Re: So What Really Killed Swing

I started going to the Bash after most people were moving on from the retro trend.  I do recall being told that everyone dressed up just a few months earlier, and that there was one guy would would always be dressed ultra-flashy 40s but he never did catch on to dancing that much [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif[/img]

I used to prefer going to the VFW though--it had a huge dance floor and you never had to worry about running in to anyone&#33;

I&#39;ll say that the other thing that makes dancing not as much fun is when you have a bunch of newbies who don&#39;t get/understand the "no aerials" rule and insist on doing them on a social dance floor (this is especially annoying when the dance floor is ultra crowded.)  Doing so is dangerous to them and others and I personally don&#39;t enjoy getting kicked because someone can&#39;t understand the reasoning behind the rule or simply ignores following it.  [img]style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/rolleyes.gif[/img]


Administrator has disabled public posting

Board Info

User Info:   Newest User :  DutFrurevense  
Online  There are no members online
Topic
New
Locked
Topic
New
Locked
Sticky
Active
New/Active
Sticky
Active
New/Active
New/Closed
New Sticky
Closed/Active
New/Locked
New Sticky
Locked/Active
Active/Sticky
Sticky/Locked
Sticky Active Locked
Active/Sticky
Sticky/Locked
Sticky/Active/Locked